Team@AlexGPR.com +1 816-945-2477

How the News Media Can Frame an Issue

The long-awaited (yet largely ignored by the public as far as I can tell) Presidential Oil Spill Commission’s final report was issued last week, with a comprehensive examination of what happened before, during and after the fateful events on BP’s Deepwater Horizon platform. Certainly within the report there is plenty of fodder for Public Relations and crisis communications pros. One thing that struck me involves the way certain members of the media decided on a frame for their stories and stuck to it.

Joel Achenbach of the Washington Post picked out this nugget about CNN’s Anderson Cooper (emphasis mine):

From Chapter Five, page 139:

Local resentment became a media theme and then a self-fulfilling prophesy. Even those who privately thought the federal government was doing the best it could under the circumstances could not say so publicly. Coast Guard responders watched Governor Jindal — and the TV cameras following him — return to what appeared to be the same spot of oiled marsh day after day to complain about the inadequacy of the federal response, even though only a small amount of marsh was then oiled. When the Coast Guard sought to clean up that piece of affected marsh, Governor Jindal refused to confirm its location. Journalists encouraged state and local officials and residents to display their anger at the federal response, and offered coverage when they did. Anderson Cooper reportedly asked a Parish President to bring an angry, unemployed offshore oil worker on his show. When the Parish President could not promise the worker would be ‘angry,’ both were disinvited.

Cooper fired back:

“This unattributed statement is completely false . . . [the claim] that it was journalists who were encouraging residents and state and local leaders to ‘display their anger at the federal response’ is offensive.”

It’s interesting to me in that public relations pros are constantly taken to the woodshed by critics for our attempts to frame an issue (click here for an interesting exploration of frame Vs. spin)–yet here is a very prominent journalist who is (if true) apparently going beyond framing an issue but actually spinning it. I throw no stones, just making an observation. To be sure, we all do it in one way or another, consciously or unconsciously.

My question is: As humans are we necessarily–despite the appeals of our better angels–at the mercy of our own preconceptions? I don’t know. But I do know that even those we hold up as being objective can be subjective in their judgment of events, issues or policies.
Please follow and like us:
LinkedIn
Share
Instagram
Twitter
Follow by Email
RSS
YouTube
Pinterest
Mastodon
error

Enjoy this blog? Please spread the word :)